How to Choose an eLearning Development Company – 15 Questions

Picking a vendor feels a bit like hiring a contractor to remodel your kitchen. Everyone has an attractive portfolio, and everyone says they're on time and on budget. You won't really know if you chose well until you're halfway through and it's too late to switch. The difference is that you can ask much sharper questions up front. How do you choose an eLearning development company that will actually deliver?

To choose an eLearning development company, ask questions that make vendors show their process, not just their portfolio. The best predictors of a good project are a clear development process with defined review rounds, honest pricing tied to scope, experience with courses like yours, and contract terms that give you the source files. Fifteen focused questions, grouped below into fit, process and money, will quickly separate the vendors who have done this many times from the ones who are hoping it works out. Score the answers, check references and run a small paid pilot if the project is large.

What Does an eLearning Development Company Do?

An eLearning development company designs and builds online training, usually from your content and subject matter experts. Most offer some mix of instructional design, writing, graphics, narration, video, course development in authoring tools, and packaging for your learning management system (LMS).

They vary considerably in focus. Some specialize in fast, template-based compliance courses, while others build custom scenarios, software simulations or 3D experiences. Some handle strategy and needs analysis, while others expect you to arrive with an approved outline, so knowing which kind you need narrows the list quickly.

What Should You Decide Before You Contact Vendors?

Before you contact vendors, decide on your audience, your goal and your rough scope. Vendors can help refine all three, but they can't quote accurately if you haven't considered them first.

• Who are the learners, and where will they take the course: at a desk, on a phone, on a shared tablet?
• What should people do differently after the training? Write it as a behavior, not a topic.
• Roughly how long is the course, how many modules, and how interactive does it need to be?
• What's your deadline, and is it real or preferred?
• What budget range has been approved, even loosely?

Sharing a budget range feels risky, but it usually helps because it allows vendors to propose an appropriate solution instead of guessing high or low.

Questions About Fit and Experience

Fit questions tell you whether the vendor has built courses like yours, for learners like yours. An excellent medical eLearning company may be the wrong choice for a manufacturing safety course.

1. Can you show two or three projects similar to ours? Similar in audience, interactivity or subject. Ask them to walk you through one, including what went wrong.
2. Who exactly would work on our project? Get names and roles. Ask whether those people are employees or subcontractors, and whether the people in the pitch are the ones who'll do the work.
3. Which authoring tools do you use, and why? The answer should depend on your needs, like mobile use, updates by your team or complex interactions, not just habit.
4. Can you build the interactivity level we need? If you're considering software simulations or virtual reality, ask for samples at that level. Understanding typical training simulation cost before this conversation helps you judge whether their numbers are realistic.
5. Can we talk to two recent clients? References from the last year or two matter more than famous logos from long ago.

Questions About Process and Quality

Process questions reveal how the project will actually function from week to week. This is where most problems originate, so devote the most time to this category.

6. What are your project phases and deliverables? Look for a clear sequence, such as design document, storyboard or prototype, alpha, beta and final, with sign-off at each step.
7. How many review rounds are included per deliverable? Many vendors build in two. Ask what happens, and what it costs, if you need a third.
8. How do you work with our subject matter experts (SMEs)? Ask how much SME time they'll need per week and how they keep reviews focused.
9. How do you test courses before delivery? Ask about their quality assurance checklist, device testing and testing in your actual LMS.
10. How do you handle accessibility? Ask which standard they build to. A solid answer references the W3C's Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG), names the level (usually AA) and describes how they test keyboard access, captions and screen reader support. If you are a U.S. federal agency or contractor, ask specifically about Section 508 conformance and who signs off on it.

The vendor who asks you the most questions in the first meeting is often the one who will give you the fewest surprises later.

Questions About Money, Ownership and Risk

Money and ownership questions protect you if the project changes, the vendor relationship ends or you need to update the course years from now. Ask them early in the conversation, while everyone is still friendly.

11. How did you build this estimate? Ask to see the hours by phase. A fixed price is fine, but it should rest on a visible estimate.
12. How do you handle change requests? Look for a written change process with an hours estimate and your approval before work starts.
13. Do we get all source files when the project is paid? You want the editable authoring files, graphics files and audio, not just the published package. Put it in the contract.
14. What's your payment schedule? Payments tied to milestones like storyboard approval and beta delivery keep both sides honest. Be cautious about large up-front payments for big projects.
15. What support do you offer after launch? Ask about a warranty period for bug fixes and the rates for future updates.

Is a Large Agency or a Small Studio the Better Choice?

Neither is better in every situation. A large agency is usually the better choice for big, multi-language programs with tight governance, and a small studio is often the better choice for focused projects where you want senior people doing the work.

Large agencies bring depth, because they can staff up quickly, cover many specialties under one roof and absorb a sick day or a resignation without your schedule slipping. The trade-off is overhead: you'll likely pay for account management layers, and the senior people from the pitch may hand off to junior staff after kickoff.

Small studios bring focus, since you often work directly with the people building your course, decisions happen quickly and rates can be lower. The trade-off is capacity, because if two of their projects peak simultaneously, or a key person leaves, your project feels the impact.

Whichever size you lean toward, ask the same question: what happens if the person we depend on most becomes unavailable? A thoughtful answer, with a named backup and documented files, is a good sign at any size.

How Do You Check References the Right Way?

Check references by asking about problems rather than praise. Every reference a vendor offers will say they were satisfied, so what you need to learn is how the vendor behaved when something went wrong.

• What was the hardest moment in the project, and how did the vendor handle it?
• Did the final cost match the original estimate? If not, why?
• How did they treat your subject matter experts' time?
• Did the course work in your LMS on the first upload?
• Would you hire them again for a harder project?

Listen carefully for hesitation on the last question, because "Yes, probably" means something very different from "Yes, we already have."

How Should You Compare the Answers?

Compare answers with a simple scoring sheet so that one charming presenter doesn't win by default. Rate each question from 1 to 3 and give extra weight to the questions that matter most for your project.

The weights are only a suggestion. If you're purchasing a straightforward compliance course, fit may matter less, but if you're purchasing something complex, process should carry even more weight. For large projects, consider paying your top two vendors to build a short sample module. A few thousand dollars spent on a pilot is cheap insurance against a six-figure mistake.

Which Red Flags Should End the Conversation?

Some answers should end the conversation, or at least make you slow down. They don't always mean the vendor is incompetent, but they reliably predict difficulties.

• A firm quote before they've asked about your audience, content or LMS.
• "Unlimited revisions." It sounds generous. In practice, it usually means no process for managing them.
• Refusing to give you source files, or charging extra for them after the fact.
• Samples they can't explain, or that turn out to be templates with a new logo.
• No questions about how success will be measured.
• A team that changes between the pitch and the kickoff.

Also observe the pace of communication during the sales process. A vendor who takes a week to answer an email when they're trying to win your business won't get faster once they have it.

Choose the eLearning Development Company That Shows Its Work

Choosing an eLearning development company comes down to evidence. Portfolios show what a vendor can produce, while their answers about process, reviews, testing, pricing and ownership show how your project will actually unfold.

Decide your audience, goal and scope first. Then ask all fifteen questions, score the answers with weights that fit your project, check recent references and, for big projects, pay for a small pilot.

The vendor worth hiring is the one who answers clearly, asks good questions back and puts their promises in writing. That combination is less common than it should be, and it's worth the extra week of searching to find it. Hold every vendor to that standard, including me; I'm happy to answer all fifteen questions in writing.

← All articles